Treating the Symptoms - the debate

We have recently been discussing here the impact of secular society on the Jewish way of life.

I think that one of the notions that has crept into our consciousness is "treating the symptoms" instead of treating things at their root.

This begins with medical treatment (see the story in "Treating the Symptoms - the Poll" thread) but infuses much of our lives. I especially see it as the basis of many educational issues, including tzniut.

Should the Jewish way of life advocate dealing with the symptoms or dealing with root of the problem?

Platinum Member Joined: Sep 20 2004 Posts: 17151

Good question Ribbie. To treat the root of the problem we need to be infusing ourselves with spiritual medicine. "Tanya" which was printed in תקנ"ו is called Ketores Neshama V'Ruach meaning it's medicine for all the ills of the neshama.

The study of Chassidus and Mussar is needed to counter the influences of the secular world on us. Without it we don't stand a chance.
_________________
Zogt Toras Emes, Toras Chaim, Horaah BaChaim: KER A VELT HEINT!

HindaRochel, if you know what Chassidus explains about that saying from Hillel, you would understand how it can encompass the entire Torah. Otherwise if you think about it, how is the rest all commentary?

TzenaRena, I've always thought it was pretty straight forward. I realize you are a Chassid, but I'm not, so you'll have to explain it from the Chassic view point. I would like to hear what you have to say on the matter.

Chassidut is the pnimiut of the Torah, aspiring to an understanding of the spiritual roots of all being.

The way I see it, Chassidut reaches the true essence of our lives, leaving no area untouched by its illuminating light. Chassidut delves into the innermost spiritual roots of our lives and reveals the hidden goodness that resides even in evil.

As TzenaRena said,