Matt Walsh "What is a Woman"

#BestBubby

Mon, Jun 13 2022, 10:13 pm

Matt talking to a PROFESSOR of GENDER STUDIES:

Matt: What is a Woman?

Professor: (long silence)......Why do you ask that question?

Matt: I would just really like to know. I'm asking because you're a college professor.
This is what you do.

Professor: What other kinds of answers have you gotten?

Matt: A lot of this - where you're not answering the question.

Professor: I think it is interesting that a lot of people have been reluctant to answer the question.
And I think it has a lot to do with the questions that preceded it.
And the way you have conducted yourself in the interview.

Matt: How have I conducted myself in this interview?

Professor: How do you think you have conducted yourself?

Matt: (laughs) You just really don't want to answer the question, do you?

Professor: I came here very willing and enthusiastic to discuss Women's s*xuality Studies

Matt: So you are willing to answer questions about Women's Studies,
The answer you should be willing to provide is: What is a Woman?

Professor: For me it's a simple answer: A person who IDENTIFIES as a Woman.

Matt: But what are they identifying AS?

Professor: As a WOMAN

Matt: So what is that???

Professor: As a WOMAN

Matt: Do you know what a CIRCULAR DEFINITION is?

Professor: I Do.

Matt: Sort of what you are doing right now (draws an Air Circle).
A woman is a woman.

Professor: You would like me to give you a set of biological or cultural attributes.

Matt: I'm not seeking any TYPE of definition. I am just seeking A definition.

Professor: I gave you one.

#BestBubby

Mon, Jun 13 2022, 10:45 pm

Excerpt from Interview with Dr. Forcier - a Pediatrician who transitions children.

Matt: How do you decide if a child is transgender

Dr: I interview them. I ask them what are you now?
And more excitingly, what would you like to be in the future?

Matt: Have you ever met a 4 year old who believes in Santa Claus?

Dr: Umm-hmm [yes]

Matt: Someone who believes a fat man is flying through the sky with flying reindeer
at lightening speed, coming down his chimney with presents

Dr. Yeah

Matt: Would you say this is someone who has a TENUOUS grasp of reality?

Dr: They have an appropriate FOUR YEAR OLD handle on reality. That's very real for them.

Matt: Agreed. Santa Clause is real for them.

Dr: Yeah

Matt: But Santa Claus is NOT actually real!

Dr: But Santa Claus does deliver their x-mas presents

Matt: Yeah, but Santa Clause is NOT actually real, though.

Dr: To that child, they are.

Matt: But I see a child who believes in Santa Claus, and let's say it's a boy and
says, "I'm a girl".

This is someone who can't distinguish between fantasy and reality.

So how can you take that [I'm a girl] as a Reality?

Dr: I would say as a Pediatrician and a Parent, "How wonderful my four year old's imagination is."
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Matt: Male Gametes - that's what makes me Male.

Dr: No, your sperm don't make you Male.

Matt: Then what does?

Dr: It's a Constellation.

Matt: In REALITY. In TRUTH.

Dr. Whose Truth are we talking about?

Matt: The same truth that says we are sitting right now in this room talking.

Dr: No, you're not listening.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Matt: If I see a chicken laying eggs and I say that is a Female Chicken did I assign a gender
or did I observe a physical reality that is happening in the world?

Dr: Does a chicken have gender identity? Does a chicken cry? Does a chicken commit suicide?

Matt: A chicken has s*x like any living organism

Dr.: A chicken has an assigned gender. But a chicken doesn't have a gender identity.

Matt: So we assign gender to a chicken when it lays eggs?

Dr: We ASSUME the chicken is Female if they lay eggs.

hodeez

Mon, Jun 13 2022, 11:29 pm

#BestBubby wrote:

"Does a chicken commit suicide?" Lunatic.

amother

Eggplant

Mon, Jun 13 2022, 11:39 pm

This is heartbreaking

The person speaking was born female

One of the most powerful scenes is Walsh’s interview with Scott (Kellie) Newgent, who transitioned from female to male after being convinced that she was “in the wrong body.” She describes her many surgeries and how much is deeply physically wrong with her today. “I will never be a man,” Newgent admits. And, after the procedures, “I’m probably not going to live very long.”
Yet, she adds, there were few discussions about side effects though “medical transition is experimental.”

—-
And on a lighter note.

At a Women’s March, Walsh chats with some women holding a sign that reads “if men could get pregnant we wouldn’t even be having this conversation.” When he asks what a woman actually is, they get flustered and end up arguing that men can, indeed, get pregnant — rendering their sign pointless.

#BestBubby

Mon, Jun 13 2022, 11:46 pm

amother [ Eggplant ] wrote:

This was very sad. A woman who "transitioned" to a man, who suffers terrible pain
and says she probably won't live very long.

Said the complication rate of transition surgery is 67% !!!

This is a terrible crime to do to children.

We don't let children buy or sell a piece of property because they might be
taken advantage of -

but Government (D) lets children irreversibly mutilate themselves - and maybe
cause their death. Certainly 40% suicide rate!

amother

Canary

Mon, Jul 10 2023, 11:16 pm

amother Chocolate wrote:

I'm about as interested in watching Matt Walsh tell me about tg issues as I am in watching a documentary about Israel by Linda Sarsour or a documentary about Judaism by Louis Farrakhan.

He’s not “telling anyone about transgender issues,” he’s asking questions to so-called transgender experts (who mostly refuse to answer).

Totally incomparable to Linda Sarsour or Louis Farrakhan, both of whom are rabidly antisemitic.

amother

Ultramarine

Tue, Jul 11 2023, 2:49 pm

So my 14 mo loves to play with cars and imitate sirens and crash two cars together making a "boom" sound. SHE also loves putting on hats and sun glasses and looking at herself in the mirror.
My 4 yo loves jewelery, flowers and always notices when I'm wearing something new calling it "pretty" and "stunning". HE also is amazing at building elaborate train tracks set ups, absolutely LOVES his electrical jeep and has the most boyish sense of humor.
My older kids are similar. My 2 oldest daughters never played with dolls or doll houses. My son did. He'll make a great father one day! My older girls loved building stuff with Legos and clicks and digging in the dirt, finding earth worms and comparing who's is longer.... now as preteens/teens they like looking good. They want to buy every fancy bag they see. They want me to make elaborate hair styles with their hair, and enjoy jewelery and climbing on monkey bars.... they want to get their nails done, they like digging into my makeup bag....
They are kids. They like what they like. That doesn't make them the opposite gender.

I used to climb the most dangerous things, I loved helping my father when he was fixing things around the house. I know a thing or two about construction becuase enjoy it. I am very much a woman!
I love being a woman. I love pampering myself. I love looking pretty. Dressing nice.... I also love mowing the lawn and killing the weeds (absolutely love love pulling them out!)
My husband is actually a very effeminate male. He's got a soft voice, and when we first met at a young age he could have passed for a girl before his facial hair grew in. (Although he was 6ft+ so that wasn't very feminine) he actually looked more feminine than his sister who has a masculine look, and a low voice......
He's an amazing husband. And no he doesn't ever do 1 thing at a time. He has adhd so he's always doing a million things at once.
He is very much a male.