I'm going to throw out some names I've heard.
Shiraz Chaim- the families I know that send there are a wonderful yeshivish with an OOT slant.
Chain Bais Yaakov- thrilled yeshivish neighbors there. They say very homey.
You could also try Bais Faiga if you could get in. Its large (11 parallel classes) but very much has the feel of an OOT BY because of the mix. (I went to an OOT BY). Only starts in primary, though.