I'd go with Crazy Stupid Love for your situation. The Princess Bride is a great movie but it's more of a silly comedy than a romantic comedy. I don't really remember CSL but I remember DH and I both thought it was funny and enjoyed it. The Proposal is more of a movie you watch with your girlfriends (romcom), and the others weren't that good.
Agree. Princess bride is a kids movie.
Crazy stupid love is not as fluffy as a regular chick flick, more the type for a guy to enjoy.
Ryan Gosling and Emma Stone have amazing chemistry. And Steve Carell is always hilarious.