Home

Title edit: frum people fostering non Jewish children
1, 2, 3  Next  Last >>
 
Post new topic   Reply to topic    Forum -> Interesting Discussions


View latest: 24h 48h 72h


southernbubby




 
 
 
 

Post  Thu, Jan 16 2020, 9:20 am
SUBSCRIBE
ESSAYSOBSERVATIONSPICKS
Why Orthodox Jews Have Been Hesitant to Adopt Outside Their Community, and Why They Shouldn't Be
Over 100,000 American children in foster care are waiting to be adopted. Orthodox and ultra-Orthodox Jews can help.


OBSERVATION
MALKA GRODEN
JAN. 14 2020
The rapid growth in the numbers of children in America who are waiting to be adopted has stimulated proactive efforts by Christian organizations to ease the burden on foster-care and adoptive families. So far, the American Jewish community has shown little desire to help.

To understand both the nature of the problem and the disparity in responses to it, a bit of background is in order, starting with the terms themselves.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Malka Groden is a domestic-adoption advocate in the American Jewish community.

For many, the word “adoption” brings to mind a biologically childless couple waiting for years to be matched with a child until the blessed day arrives when they can bring their infant home from the hospital. That scenario does indeed describe one type of adoption: the private type. This usually involves the services of an adoption agency or a private lawyer hired to match prospective parents with a pregnant woman who makes her choice by looking through colorful booklets of smiling couples. Should those prospective parents be open to a non-white child, or a child exposed in utero to drugs or alcohol, they will often be matched more quickly.

But then there’s public adoption, which is managed through the foster-care system: an arrangement for children whose parents, for one reason or another, are unable to care for them. Typically, the goal in foster care is reunification with the child’s biological family; in the interim, such a child might be placed with relatives, or with foster parents, or in a group home. Only if reunification becomes impossible are the biological parents’ rights terminated and the child freed for adoption.

Foster-care children are rarely infants. Some are sibling sets; others have experienced some form of trauma, abuse, and/or neglect; in the case of some, one or both parents may be incarcerated. More than one-third of the children entering the foster-care system have been removed from their homes at least in part because of parental substance abuse.

In short: in private adoption, prospective parents wait impatiently to be matched with a single child. In the world of public adoption, legions of children are waiting to be matched with a home. According to AFCARS, the federal service that tracks child-welfare cases, the number of American children entering the foster-care system has increased over the last five years. By the close of 2017, out of a reported total of 437,000 children in foster care, 123,000 were waiting to be adopted.



In trying to copewith this burgeoning challenge, a number of states, especially those ravaged by the opioid crisis, have been overhauling their foster-care system with an eye toward more actively recruiting foster and adoptive parents. Still, the actual process of fostering a child remains, understandably, extensive and burdensome. Along with a background check to make sure a home is appropriate, prospective families are required to undergo state-mandated training. This involves a number of sessions (varying both within each state and from state to state) to prepare for parenting a child who might have been through trauma, abuse, and/or multiple foster-care placements.

Fortunately, the efforts by public institutions to fill the void of desperately needed families have recently been augmented as, across the country, church communities and evangelical Christian organizations have mobilized to partner with state agencies. These churches and grassroots initiatives tend to know up-close the difficulties faced by those who volunteer to foster and adopt or are thinking of doing so—and especially how hard it is to navigate the process alone. In enlisting the help of local pastors and religious leaders, they have linked the good deed of helping needy and vulnerable children to the principles animating their faith, all in the cause of supplying a crucial missing element in the process: communal support, both practical and emotional.

LATEST IN OBSERVATIONS
In a 2018 essay for the Atlantic, Naomi Schaefer Riley described three such organizations—Project 1:27, the CALL, and Restore Hope—that work to alleviate the burden on prospective foster families through a network of other families of faith who are either going through the same process or have been educated to understand its realities and can provide effective support. Thus, families are strongly encouraged (and sometimes required) to bring a friend to training sessions who will be equipped to step in and help when the new foster parents will inevitably need a day off. Local pastors are encouraged to speak and give guidance on this subject and to promote an adoptive- and foster-family-friendly atmosphere in their churches.

On a practical level, these organizations provide anything from a more convenient schedule of training sessions to a babysitting room where volunteers care for a family’s other children during parental sessions. The CALL, in Arkansas, has even built a fully stocked “thrift shop” with free diapers, clothes, and toiletries for families who have suddenly been placed with a foster child.

Efforts like these have indeed made some headway toward recruiting and supporting foster and adoptive parents. But the need for more homes remains urgent. In New York State alone, where no such bridge organizations exist, there are currently 3,500 children waiting for adoptive families.



What, then,of the Jews—another faith community with a substantial presence in large cities and a broad communal infrastructure? So far, the involvement of American Jews in this cause has been minimal. Nor does there seem any reason to think that some significant portion of the Jewish community might become galvanized to act.

For one thing, as survey data from the last several years have confirmed, American Jews in general are themselves marrying later, having fewer if any children, and showing minimal connection to any form of organized Jewish life with its many resources for communal support. According to a 2017 study published by the Jewish People Policy Institute and authored by the sociologists Sylvia Barack Fishman and Steven M. Cohen, only 15 percent of non-ḥaredi (“ultra-Orthodox”) Jews between the ages of twenty-five and fifty-four are forming Jewish families and raising Jewish children; 30-35 percent are unmarried and have no children; and the remainder are largely intermarried or without children.

If a sizable percentage of non-ḥaredi Jews—that is to say, a sizable percentage of most Jews in this age range—are not forming families to begin with, they are unlikely to become directly involved in adoption and/or foster care.

There is, however, one group of American Jews who are indeed marrying young, having children, and building families deeply connected to Jewish communal infrastructure through synagogues, schools, and a broad range of support organizations. That group comprises both the Ḥaredim and the modern Orthodox, who, although together making up only a minority of affiliated American Jews, are uniquely committed to their traditions and their communities.

Sign up for our e-mail list
Get the latest from Mosaic right in your inbox

Your e-mail
SIGN UP
DAILY
WEEKLY
In recent decades, indeed, the Orthodox world has become adept at devising arrangements in support of individuals and families going through life’s most significant challenges: medical crises, infertility, domestic violence, drug addiction, poverty, and more. The organization In Shifra’s Arms, for example, supports, emotionally, practically, and financially, Jewish women facing unplanned pregnancies; for another example, the Jewish Children’s Adoption Network has placed thousands of Jewish babies with special needs in Jewish homes nationwide.

But there’s the rub: float within Orthodox precincts any suggestion of becoming involved with the issue of foster care and adoption in the larger society, and the initial response will likely be, “But those children aren’t Jewish. Why is this a Jewish cause?”

As it happens, there is an answer to that question that is of special relevance to Orthodox and ḥaredi Jews. To grasp it, one need only turn to the perspective on the Jewish family propounded by two towering Jewish leaders and thinkers of the 20th century: Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneersohn, the “Lubavitcher Rebbe,” and Rabbi Joseph B. Soloveitchik, the “Rav”: the one the innovative leader of the ḥasidic movement known as Chabad, the other the pre-eminent theologian and doyen of modern Orthodoxy.



The Lubavitcher Rebbeis famous for sending his emissaries throughout the world to bring Judaism and Jewish resources to Jews wherever they might be found, thereby building a mass network of Jewish centers worldwide.

Initially, the Rebbe’s vision for outreach came as a shock to the Orthodox world, involving as it did the spectacle of young Orthodox men and women picking up their roots and relocating to distant corners of the globe as emissaries of Chabad or perhaps approaching business people on the streets of midtown Manhattan asking if they’re Jewish and then urging them to don phylacteries or light Sabbath candles. Dismissing objections to this practice, the Rebbe stressed that it was a Jew’s mission to multiply opportunities for good deeds and the chance for any and all Jews to connect to their Creator.

More broadly, the Rebbe taught that Jews are tasked with revealing not only their own “divine spark” but also the divine spark that resides within each human being, Jew and non-Jew alike. Thus, among Chabad’s initiatives was a campaign to include, at the start of each day in the nation’s public schools, a moment of silence during which all children would have an opportunity to contemplate their own purpose and responsibilities. Similarly, the Rebbe pushed for criminal-justice reform—stressing that those incarcerated must be given the chance for rehabilitation so that they too can return to their God-given mission in life—at a time when this issue did not command the broad consensus it enjoys today.

Both of these projects, geared simultaneously toward Jews and the broader community, reflected the Rebbe’s firmly activist view of the essential worth of each human being. With a proper moral foundation and education, he held, every individual, however highly or humbly situated, has the potential to grow and reveal his or her own divine spark. It is the mission of Jews to advance that project through whatever means they can: teaching Torah, helping to build a soup kitchen, giving charity, or adopting and parenting a non-Jewish child in desperate need of a stable, loving home.

Meanwhile, Rabbi Soloveitchik, coming at the issue from his own direction, devoted an entire volume of essays, Family Redeemed, to the theme of family relationships. In one of these essays, he describes two forms of parenthood.

The first form, “natural parenthood,” is represented by Adam and Eve. The motherhood of Eve is instinctual and all-consuming; her entire being is involved, through the nine months of pregnancy and onward through the physical and biological demands of childbirth and child rearing. For Adam, by contrast, fathering a child makes no biological claims at all; after the child’s birth, he is free to act exactly as he did before.

With Abraham and Sarah, a new form—“covenantal” or “redeemed” parenthood—is revealed. For the first time, fatherhood demands something of men: Abraham must serve as an educator, molding his children and the next generation. In this mission, Sarah, the redeemed mother, joins him as partner and essential link in the transmission of the covenant. Separate from the biological demands made on her as a mother, motherhood takes on a larger ethical meaning to which she in turn makes a free commitment. At the start of the Jewish people’s history, God confers on the first foremother and forefather the chance to move beyond the innate ties of biology and assume a trans-generational mission.



Thus,where the Lubavitcher Rebbe’s teachings clarify the nature of the core Jewish mission, Rabbi Soloveitchik’s conception of covenantal parenthood provides the framework in which that mission can be fulfilled through the specific medium of the Jewish family.

What does this mean for our subject here? It means that by moving a child from the darkness of abuse, neglect, and trauma and embracing that child in their home, a Jewish family steps into the shoes of Abraham and Sarah. Theirs is by definition not an act of biological reproduction but of covenantal redemptiveness: a pledge to cultivate the child’s God-given dignity and worth and, in so doing, exemplify and advance the essential mission of a Jew.

In this regard, pathbreaking Christian efforts to recruit and support adoptive and foster families can serve as a model for nascent Jewish ones, especially within the religiously observant communities of Orthodox and ḥaredi Jews. Those Christian efforts have also shown that not everyone is called upon exclusively to foster or adopt; equally important are those who can help support families financially and emotionally.

By learning from the remarkable work done by American Christians, and by actualizing the core Jewish mission through the redemptive power of the Jewish family, American Jews can begin to help bring healing to a generation of children wounded and forgotten.

LATEST IN OBSERVATIONS

More About: AdoptionPolitics & Current Affairs

POPULAR ON MOSAIC

How to Judge Robert Alter's Landmark Translation of the Hebrew Bible
ESSAYHILLEL HALKIN

Why It's Necessary to Bring Jewish Communism into Full View
RESPONSERUTH R. WISSE

RSS
About Us
Our Authors
Legal
© 2016 Mosaic
Welcome to Mosaic
Register now to get two more stories FREE.

REGISTER NOW
Already a subscriber? Sign in now


Last edited by southernbubby on Thu, Jan 16 2020, 11:08 am; edited 1 time in total
Back to top

zaq




 
 
 
 

Post  Thu, Jan 16 2020, 9:46 am
Glittering words, but the idea is totally impractical en masse and problematic on multiple levels.

Reminds me of the nonsensical declaration of the left-wing “tikun olamniks” that we should stop lighting Chanuka licht because of the contribution to global warming. Riiight. For eight days, less than 0.2% of the earth’s population lights a few small candles for half an hour and that’s causing global warming—not the garish 24/7 displays of Xmas lights that burn for months, not the razing of millions of trees that are later discarded, not the gas-guzzling cars coming off the assembly line, not the utterly wasteful heating, cooling and lighting of spaces that are barely occupied...no, it’s those evil Chanuka lights.

Amazing how willing left-wing secular Jews are to ditch their own traditions and preserve everyone else’s. I suggest THEY start fostering or adopting these unwanted children. After all, even with their small family sizes, as a group they outnumber Orthodox Jews by a lot.
Back to top

Ruchel




 
 
 
 

Post  Thu, Jan 16 2020, 9:48 am
I see Orthodox adopting and converting very regularly
Back to top

amother




Natural
 

Post  Thu, Jan 16 2020, 9:48 am
It is very difficult or impossible for frum Jews to be foster parents for the foster care system in the USA.

The application scares people off. And if someone does fill it out, the foster care system will REJECT them.

Example of question on application? Any mental illness in the family?
Now which holocaust survivor, siberia survivor descendant can answer without fear of scrutiny ( or magnifying glass CPS or ACS children services wonderful "know it all" arrogant people.)

Another question: were you or husband ever on meds??
Now who in their right mind will answer that one. You will have the CPS decide that the pizza and french fries thursday nite supper is the parenting crime of the century. (the veggies are missing!!! oh what a felony!"
Ironically, many of these people on meds are best equipped to understand motherless/traumatized/troubled adolescents...

Christians on the other hand usually have a non jewish ruigkeit (peacefulness),living in stable conditions for the past few generations...

Their application is "clean" and they look good on paper.

So, PLEASE DO NOT COMPARE APPLES TO WHEAT.

Many of us gladly took into our homes children/ teenagers with major issues as long as we dont have the KGB of children services eying us with prejudiced eyes.....
Back to top

amother




Pumpkin
 

Post  Thu, Jan 16 2020, 9:53 am
zaq wrote:
Glittering words, but the idea is totally impractical en masse and problematic on multiple levels.

Reminds me of the nonsensical declaration of the left-wing “tikun olamniks” that we should stop lighting Chanuka licht because of the contribution to global warming. Riiight. For eight days, less than 0.2% of the earth’s population lights a few small candles for half an hour and that’s causing global warming—not the garish 24/7 displays of Xmas lights that burn for months, not the razing of millions of trees that are later discarded, not the gas-guzzling cars coming off the assembly line, not the utterly wasteful heating, cooling and lighting of spaces that are barely occupied...no, it’s those evil Chanuka lights.

Amazing how willing left-wing secular Jews are to ditch their own traditions and preserve everyone else’s. I suggest THEY start fostering or adopting these unwanted children. After all, even with their small family sizes, as a group they outnumber Orthodox Jews by a lot.


Author is a frum woman.
Back to top

Ruchel




 
 
 
 

Post  Thu, Jan 16 2020, 9:53 am
I do not consider my family has having mental illness and I'm second gen. I also was not on mental meds, and have no problem saying I take migraine meds. The application is difficult ime money wise because many countries demand a "not low" salary (China is terrible), also a huge place that is set like a professional etc. I saw it when we wanted to adopt. Had no problem with the scrutiny on medical stuff. Yes, they're arrogant, that's true and it's annoying
Back to top

amother




Pewter
 

Post  Thu, Jan 16 2020, 9:56 am
There are people who should consider this. It would be ridiculous for the vast majority, but for the handful of people this could work for, it's a good idea.
Back to top

southernbubby




 
 
 
 

Post  Thu, Jan 16 2020, 10:09 am
I guess what struck me about it is that:

1) Non frum Jews are becoming increasingly disinterested in being parents, at least according to the author of the article.

2) I can't see making kids drop whatever religious beliefs they have and embrace ours. My non-frum brother adopted kids from foster care and one was raised in a Catholic foster care facility and has strong X-tian beliefs. A friend of my brother's offered to take the kid to church but now he is old enough to go on his own.
Back to top

amother




Khaki
 

Post  Thu, Jan 16 2020, 10:14 am
The Jews in Russia have fared very well under Putin. I've read that as a child, he grew up impoverished, with neglectful parents. His Jewish neighbors always invited him in, fed the hungry, neglected child - when they themselves did not have much to eat. To this day he has "hakoras hatov" to the Jewish people. Of course, we do good deeds not expecting reward, but you never know what your chesed will lead to.
Back to top

amother




Pumpkin
 

Post  Thu, Jan 16 2020, 10:20 am
southernbubby wrote:
I guess what struck me about it is that:

1) Non frum Jews are becoming increasingly disinterested in being parents, at least according to the author of the article.

2) I can't see making kids drop whatever religious beliefs they have and embrace ours. My non-frum brother adopted kids from foster care and one was raised in a Catholic foster care facility and has strong X-tian beliefs. A friend of my brother's offered to take the kid to church but now he is old enough to go on his own.


SB - the author of the article is a Chabad woman who has adopted. She's just sharing an opinion - not issuing a directive.
Back to top

amother




Cerulean
 

Post  Thu, Jan 16 2020, 10:25 am
Jews don’t believe in ‘taking in’ and converting people as a goal. Christians do and that’s the essential difference here.
Back to top

southernbubby




 
 
 
 

Post  Thu, Jan 16 2020, 10:38 am
amother [ Pumpkin ] wrote:
SB - the author of the article is a Chabad woman who has adopted. She's just sharing an opinion - not issuing a directive.


It looks like she feels that the frum community should be involved in solving the issue for the greater community. It may be a perfect solution for some frum people who want to be parents but I don't think that we should be viewed as a solution to the problem.
I can't see trying to accommodate the child's religious needs in a frum home. Babies and small children who don't yet have a religious identity would be a better match but there are questions about whether or not we should do this when the goal is to return the child to his non Jewish parents.
I agree with her entirely that Jews who want to adopt should consider this as an option.
I also wonder if there are enough frum foster parents for the Jews who need it.
Back to top

amother




Chocolate
 

Post  Thu, Jan 16 2020, 10:46 am
Fostering is extremely complicated and a painful process. Many of the children who have been through the system were abused and neglected. I don't think the average person is capable of taking in a foster child, especially if they have other children at home.

Those who do foster don't always get to adopt, the goal is reunification. It's heartbreaking to pour your soul into a child a love them deeply only to have them returned back to parents who don't have the tools to raise them properly.
(Speaking from my experience with people who have gone through the system or fostered to adopt)

I agree that the foster care system is messed up, and something needs to be done. I don't think it's such a simple solution.
Back to top

amother




Pumpkin
 

Post  Thu, Jan 16 2020, 10:51 am
southernbubby wrote:
It looks like she feels that the frum community should be involved in solving the issue for the greater community. It may be a perfect solution for some frum people who want to be parents but I don't think that we should be viewed as a solution to the problem.
I can't see trying to accommodate the child's religious needs in a frum home. Babies and small children who don't yet have a religious identity would be a better match but there are questions about whether or not we should do this when the goal is to return the child to his non Jewish parents.
I agree with her entirely that Jews who want to adopt should consider this as an option.
I also wonder if there are enough frum foster parents for the Jews who need it.


I'm just pointing out that you should be taking what she is saying in the context its written. Its similar to a young person writing a persuasive essay on a topic they care strongly about and researched. She's not an authority figure.... its reaonsble to disagree with her... it just seemed your reaction to her was rather harsh.

I think social workers are helpful in helping to determine the likleyhood of sucess of any adoption of an older child.
Back to top

southernbubby




 
 
 
 

Post  Thu, Jan 16 2020, 11:06 am
amother [ Pumpkin ] wrote:
I'm just pointing out that you should be taking what she is saying in the context its written. Its similar to a young person writing a persuasive essay on a topic they care strongly about and researched. She's not an authority figure.... its reaonsble to disagree with her... it just seemed your reaction to her was rather harsh.

I think social workers are helpful in helping to determine the likleyhood of sucess of any adoption of an older child.


Do you think that I should edit the title? I remember now that I read another article that the author wrote about her adoption of biracial infants. It was a heartwarming article and think that she was very smart to become a mother this way.
My brother, who only fosters adoptable older boys, doesn't find that most social workers are that helpful. Some of the kids have permanent psychological damage but it is hard to find a social worker who will admit that.
Back to top

amother




Chocolate
 

Post  Thu, Jan 16 2020, 11:09 am
amother [ Pumpkin ] wrote:

I think social workers are helpful in helping to determine the likleyhood of sucess of any adoption of an older child.


Occasionally desperate caseworkers make it seem like adoption is more likely than it really is.
Back to top

southernbubby




 
 
 
 

Post  Thu, Jan 16 2020, 11:10 am
I edited the title to something less harsh sounding.
Back to top

amother




Pumpkin
 

Post  Thu, Jan 16 2020, 11:16 am
southernbubby wrote:
Do you think that I should edit the title? I remember now that I read another article that the author wrote about her adoption of biracial infants. It was a heartwarming article and think that she was very smart to become a mother this way.
My brother, who only fosters adoptable older boys, doesn't find that most social workers are that helpful. Some of the kids have permanent psychological damage but it is hard to find a social worker who will admit that.


I did think your title was a bit 'click baity'.
Back to top

southernbubby




 
 
 
 

Post  Thu, Jan 16 2020, 11:21 am
amother [ Pumpkin ] wrote:
I did think your title was a bit 'click baity'.

On the new title - the article is about adoption, not fostering.


She mentioned both.
Back to top

amother




Pumpkin
 

Post  Thu, Jan 16 2020, 11:24 am
southernbubby wrote:
She mentioned both.


edited.

I think she starts with adoption and then makes an argument for temporary fostering. Its one of the reasons there are problems with the peice.
Back to top
1, 2, 3  Next  Last >> Recent Topics

Page 1 of 3 View latest: 24h 48h 72h


Post new topic   Reply to topic    Forum -> Interesting Discussions

Related Topics Replies Last Post
Miami frum neighborhoods?
by birdy
1 Wed, Jan 20 2021, 2:37 pm View last post
Massive amounts of homeless people being moved to Boro Park
by amother
204 Wed, Jan 20 2021, 12:31 pm View last post
How do people manage?? Tips please!
by amother
3 Wed, Jan 20 2021, 11:20 am View last post
Jewish book recs for 7 y.o. DD
by amother
6 Wed, Jan 20 2021, 8:34 am View last post
Longest lasting, non drying, Frosted Lipstick?
by amother
6 Tue, Jan 19 2021, 4:27 pm View last post