I did many segulas and bh was answered!

amother

Sun, Dec 17 2023, 10:42 pm

I did many different segulas over the years for a specific yeshua and bh was answered. A few of the segulas 'require' one to be mefarsem the nes, so I'm writing a list of the segulas I did. This is to publicly thank hashem for his incredible kindness in answering my teffilos.
"Hodu lashem ki tov ki leolam chasdo":
Numerous times of perek shira 40 days in a row.
Mincha 40 days in a row.
The letter in the menorah on zos chanukah.
Lighting a candle liluy nishmas R' Menachem Mendel Mriminov every Tues.
The segula of Rav Matiya ben Charish.
Endless hafrashos challah.
Daily tehillim.
Tosefos shabbos.

"Yeshuas hashem kheref ayin"!

Cheiny

Sun, Dec 17 2023, 11:07 pm

amother Skyblue wrote:

It's wonderful that you got your yeshsua but let me be clear.

You were not answered due to those segulos.

The only segula is Emuna, bitochin, doing mitzvos and tehillim.

Exactly. No one is privy to what specific thing, if any, is what caused Hashem to grant them a yeshua.

The proof is in the fact that OP says she did numerous ones… so why were numerous necessary? Shouldn’t one have done the trick if segulos were a guarantee for yeshua?

This is just false. Numerous rabbonim have the said the best segula is tefila, period. And even then, sometimes the answer is no.

If segulos were a guarantee to work, no one would be suffering with any problem. They’d all be immediately cured with the segulos.

ChossidMom

Mon, Dec 18 2023, 3:34 am

amother Skyblue wrote:

It's wonderful that you got your yeshsua but let me be clear.

You were not answered due to those segulos.

The only segula is Emuna, bitochin, doing mitzvos and tehillim.

Most of the segulos OP mentioned are mitzvos and davening. Davening is always good.
So let's be clear. OP davened and had a yeshua. Sounds good to me!
Thanks for telling us OP and further hatzlacha.

I often (maybe not "often" but as often as I can) do Rabi Matya ben Charash whether or not I know the source. What on earth can be wrong with lighting candles l'ilui nishmas and saying Tehilim!!!
The more, the better, I say. Same for R' Menachem Mendel miRiminov.

And, btw it sounds very lofty to talk about "Emuna, bitochin, doing mitzvos and tehillim". Well, that's what the OP did! Sitting down to daven in whatever way shows that OP believes in Hashem's power to help her so she turned to him. Or taking challah and davening to Hashem. Or saying Perek Shira.
Or adding on 10 minutes to Shabbos.

Sheesh. Here we go again with the age old argument. Yes segulos. No segulos. Why can't you just ignore OP's post if you disagree with her spiritual hanhagos instead of pointing out how wrong she is? Or patting her on the back for DOING MITZVOS AND DAVENING, which is not something that any of us are doing at this moment of cruising around imamother and fixing everybody else's neshamos?